Isabella Assigned The Job To He And I Or Him And I

Colin Whitehouse

less than a minute read

·

09-12-2024

11

0

Share

The correct phrasing is "Isabella assigned the job to him and me."

This seemingly simple sentence highlights a common grammatical confusion involving pronoun case. Let's break down why "him and me" is correct and why the other options are incorrect.

Understanding Pronoun Case

Pronouns have different forms depending on their grammatical function in a sentence. These forms are called cases:

• Nominative Case: Used for subjects of verbs (who is performing the action). Examples: I, you, he, she, it, we, they.
• Objective Case: Used for objects of verbs or prepositions (who is receiving the action or about whom something is said). Examples: me, you, him, her, it, us, them.

Analyzing the Sentence

In the sentence "Isabella assigned the job to him and me," the phrase "him and me" is the object of the preposition "to." Therefore, we need the objective case pronouns.

Let's examine why the other options are incorrect:

• "He and I": This uses the nominative case. While "He and I" would be correct as the subject of the sentence (e.g., "He and I assigned the job to John"), it's incorrect as the object.

• "Him and I": This mixes cases, using the objective "him" correctly but incorrectly using the nominative "I." This is grammatically inconsistent and incorrect.

A Simple Test

To determine the correct pronoun, try the sentence without the conjunction:

• Would you say "Isabella assigned the job to I"? No. The correct phrasing is "Isabella assigned the job to me."
• Therefore, adding "him" to this makes the correct form "Isabella assigned the job to him and me."

Conclusion

While grammatical rules might seem rigid, understanding pronoun case helps ensure clear and grammatically correct writing. Always use the objective case for objects of verbs and prepositions. In this instance, "Isabella assigned the job to him and me" is the only grammatically accurate option.